How to AvoidBroker Scams
How long-distance moving scams actually work, and the one question that exposes them: from a licensed San Diego carrier, not a broker.
Quick answer: the biggest long-distance moving scams start with brokers: middlemen who quote low online, take your deposit, then sell your move to an unknown carrier. Protect yourself by verifying the DOT number of the actual company, getting the flat rate in writing before loading, and never paying a large deposit to someone who does not own trucks.
How the Broker Trap Works
You fill out a form on a slick website, get a surprisingly low quote by phone, and pay a deposit. What you may not realize: that company owns no trucks. They auction your move to whichever carrier accepts it cheapest. On moving day a truck you have never heard of arrives, reweighs or remeasures your belongings, and the price jumps, sometimes double. Refuse, and your belongings may sit in a warehouse until you pay. Federal regulators receive thousands of these hostage-load complaints every year.
Broker vs. Carrier: The One Question That Matters
Ask any long-distance mover: "Are you the carrier, or a broker?" A carrier owns the trucks and employs the crew that shows up. A broker sells your job. Discount Movers is a carrier (family owned in San Diego since 1997, US DOT #4372335, CAL-T #201759) and the company that quotes your move is the company that loads, drives, and delivers it.
Five Checks Before You Book Any Long-Distance Move
- Verify the DOT number on the FMCSA website. It shows whether they are registered as a carrier or broker, their fleet size, and complaint history. Our legal resources page has the direct lookup links.
- Get the flat rate in writing before loading. A binding quote should not change unless you add items.
- Beware deposits over a few hundred dollars: large upfront deposits are the classic broker pattern. We require no deposit to book.
- Check the physical address. A real carrier has a yard full of trucks; brokers have a call center.
- Read reviews for the delivery experience, not just pickup day. That is where broker moves fall apart.
How to Check a DOT Number in Two Minutes
Every interstate household mover has to hold a US DOT number, and the register is public. Put the number into the FMCSA SAFER company snapshot and you get the legal name, the operating authority, whether that authority is active, the fleet size and the crash record. A broker and a carrier look different in that record: a carrier reports trucks and drivers, a broker reports broker authority and no fleet.
Ours is US DOT #4372335, and we would rather you look it up than take our word for it. In California the household goods authority is separate and comes from the Bureau of Household Goods and Services, which is what a CAL-T number carries. Ours is CAL-T #201759.
The Deposit Is the Tell
A deposit request is the single clearest signal in this whole subject. A company that has not seen your load, has not assigned a truck and has not agreed a price in writing has no reason to hold your money, and money held before a survey is the leverage that makes the rest of the trap work. We do not take deposits. Not a card on file, not a holding fee, not a percentage.
The pattern to watch for is a low telephone quote, a deposit taken quickly, then a revised price once the load is on the truck and your leverage is gone. The price should be agreed in writing before anything is loaded, and it should be one flat rate for the whole move rather than an estimate that can move.
A Delivery Date, Not a Delivery Window
Ask whether the delivery is a date or a window. A window is how a broker describes a load it has not placed with a driver yet, and a two week window is not a schedule, it is an admission. We give a delivery date, and it comes off simple arithmetic: about 550 miles a day, counted from the day after we load. Anything within 200 miles, which includes Los Angeles, is delivered the same day we load.
If a company cannot tell you the date, it usually cannot tell you the driver either, and those are the same problem wearing two hats.
What Booking a Carrier Looks Like Instead
One company accountable door to door. Our own 26-foot trucks and background-checked crews, a flat rate locked before we load, and delivery dates we control because we do the driving. See our long distance moving page or any of our state-by-state route pages for transit times and details.
Questions about a quote you got somewhere else? Call us at (858) 490-0155. We will tell you honestly what to watch for, whether you book with us or not.
Free Quote
GET YOUR FREE QUOTE
We respond within 2 hours during business hours (8am–8pm daily). No commitment.
What Federal Rules Require of a Broker
The rules a broker has to follow are the ones a scam broker skips. Under the federal household goods rules summarized on FMCSA's Movers vs. Brokers page, a broker must have a written agreement in place with a mover before it gives you an estimate, and it must give you a list of the moving companies it uses. Its advertising has to state its physical business location. If the company will not name the carriers it works with, it is either hiding them or has not chosen one yet.
The disclosure rule matters just as much. A broker is required to give you full written disclosure, in advance of the move, explaining that the actual charges may differ from the estimated charges and the reasons why. Read that document instead of relying on the phone quote. The quote is what gets you to sign; the disclosure is what the broker will point to when the price goes up on moving day. A carrier that agrees one flat rate in writing before loading does not need that kind of paper, because the number it gave you is the number it charges.
The Paperwork a Legitimate Mover Provides
Before an interstate move, movers and brokers alike are required to give you two FMCSA publications, the booklet Your Rights and Responsibilities When You Move and the Ready to Move brochure. FMCSA's consumer rights page lists both. A company that has never heard of the booklet, or says it will send it once you have paid, is showing you how closely it follows the rest of the rules. Ask for both documents when you ask for the estimate, and read the booklet before you sign anything.
The estimate itself has to rest on a physical survey of your household goods, conducted on site or virtually, so the mover can actually see what it will be carrying. A number produced from a phone call and a room count does not meet that standard. Each of these is something you can ask for by name, and each is usually missing from a broker sale.
Every interstate mover must have an arbitration program for disputes about loss, damage and charges, and it has to give you a concise summary of that program before you sign the bill of lading. FMCSA's dispute guidance describes the requirement, and the program must meet the elements FMCSA sets out. Ask who runs the program and how a claim gets filed. If nobody can answer, the company is either not the carrier or is not following the rules a carrier is bound by.
The 110 Percent Rule at Delivery
If you accepted a non-binding estimate, federal rules cap what the mover can demand when the truck arrives. Under FMCSA's delivery rules, a mover may not collect more than 110 percent of a non-binding estimate at destination for the services and quantities shown on that estimate. If the final bill comes in above that figure, the rule still limits what can be demanded at the door to 110 percent. Holding a load for more than 110 percent is one of the complaints FMCSA specifically lists as eligible for its complaint database.
The rule has two exceptions worth knowing before moving day. The mover can require payment at delivery for additional services you requested after the contract was signed that were not on the estimate, and it can charge for impracticable operations at delivery within the limit the rule sets. Both are narrow, and neither covers the "your load weighed more than we thought" price jump that broker moves rely on. Have 110 percent of the estimate available at delivery, as the rules require, and refuse anything past it until your goods are off the truck.
The cap only exists because a non-binding estimate can move. A flat rate agreed in writing before loading, which is how we quote, leaves no estimate to exceed, so the 110 percent calculation never comes up on a move we carry. When you compare quotes, ask each company whether its figure is binding or non-binding and whether you will have that answer on paper before the first box is loaded. A company that hesitates on either question is describing the move it intends to sell you, not the one it intends to perform.
Where to Report a Broker or a Mover
FMCSA takes complaints about movers, brokers and auto transporters through its National Consumer Complaint Database at nccdb.fmcsa.dot.gov, or by phone at 1-888-DOT-SAFT (1-888-368-7238), which is staffed 8am–8pm Eastern, Monday through Friday. Eligible complaints include a shipment held hostage for payment above 110 percent of a non-binding estimate, a company operating interstate without FMCSA authority, and a mover that failed to honor agreed pickup or delivery dates without proper notice. File as soon as the problem starts, with the estimate, the bill of lading and any texts or emails attached.
For a move that starts and ends inside California, the regulator is the Bureau of Household Goods and Services, which licenses and regulates moving companies in the state. The Bureau's online license search lets you verify a mover's license before you hire, and the Bureau's own advice is to check every time. It also publishes a complaint form for household mover complaints. Our CAL-T #201759 is the number to look up there.
Common Questions